US EditionYoung Sherlock Review: TV’s Most Famous Detective Is Finally More than Just a Canny Crime Solver in This Electric New Prime Video Show
The series reimagines Sherlock Holmes as a 19-year-old pickpocket forming an uneasy alliance with James Moriarty amid a murder and international conspiracy, premiering on Amazon Prime Video.
- On March 4, Amazon Prime Video will stream all eight episodes of Young Sherlock, produced and directed by Guy Ritchie and starring Hero Fiennes Tiffin as a 19-year-old Sherlock.
- Soon, with Princess Gulan Shou'an's arrival, Sherlock is thrust into murders exposing a wider conspiracy at Oxford University.
- The show's biggest creative issue is reworking Moriarty–Sherlock dynamic by making Moriarty a friend, which critics say undermines his future role as Sherlock's archenemy, despite engaging visuals and chemistry.
- Critics say early reviews call Young Sherlock "good fun" but argue it misses the mark as an origin story, with adaptation debates fueled by the season's lost focus and strong ensemble cast.
- Its sweeping scale suggests that if renewed, creators Peter Harness, Guy Ritchie, and Matthew Parkhill say there's scope to develop the Sherlock–Moriarty relationship more convincingly.
21 Articles
21 Articles
Review: 'R.J. Decker' and 'Young Sherlock' offer distinctive tales of the prisoner-to-PI pipeline
ABC's 'R.J. Decker' stars Scott Speedman as the titular detective reminiscent of Jim Rockford, whereas Prime Video's 'Young Sherlock' gives Arthur Conan Doyle's sleuth an origin story.
'Young Sherlock' Review: Guy Ritchie Returns to the Great Detective With a Fun but Convoluted Series
Guy Ritchie is back on TV, and this time he’s tackling a character he’s already brought to the big screen. After making two widely successful “Sherlock Holmes” films, Ritchie is turning back the clock to produce and direct “Young Sherlock,” from showrunner Matthew Parkhill. Out of the gate, this is a bit of a strange project, as it is neither a faithful adaptation of Andrew Lane’s “Young Sherlock Holmes” books, nor a proper prequel to Ritchie’s …
Young Sherlock review: TV’s most famous detective is finally more than just a canny crime solver in this electric new Prime Video show
Young Sherlock on Prime Video proves it’s still possible to reinvent an old classic — or that you need Guy Ritchie to make it unforgettable.
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 50% of the sources lean Left
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
