'Two-tier justice' row: Government plans to change law to overrule Sentencing Council
- Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood stated there will "never be a two-tier sentencing approach under my watch" amid controversy over sentencing guidelines.
- The Sentencing Council refused Shabana Mahmood's request to reconsider its new instructions for judges.
- Mahmood claimed the new guidelines "amount to differential treatment" by favoring certain minority groups for pre-sentence reports.
- Robert Jenrick described any government action as "too little too late.
29 Articles
29 Articles


Ministers mull axing Sentencing Council as law to reverse guidance is drawn up
Legislation will be introduced to overturn the Sentencing Council guidance after ‘two-tier justice’ claims. A new law to reverse “damaging” guidance on the sentencing of offenders from minorities will not be passed before Easter, despite the Government’s promise to rush it through Parliament. The guidance, which has led to accusations of “two-tier justice”, comes into force on Tuesday. Ministers have promised legislation to overturn the guidance…
Justice Secretary ‘Considering All Her Options’ on Sentencing Council: Minister
The justice secretary is “considering all her options” when it comes to the Sentencing Council, a Home Office minister has suggested. Dame Angela Eagle said Shabana Mahmood is “considering the best way to make progress” after the body refused a request to reconsider its guidance on how offenders from minorities should be sentenced. The government is set to introduce a law change in Parliament to override the new guidance for judges, which says a…
Ethnic Minorities Prioritized for Bail in Two-Tier System · Caldron Pool
Newly revealed Ministry of Justice guidance instructs UK judges to prioritize bail hearings for ethnic minorities, women, and transgender defendants. In other words, everyone other than straight, White, males. According to The Telegraph, the policy advises courts to consider “historical trauma” and the impact of racism—potentially even suffered by a suspect’s ancestors—when deciding whether to grant bail. Judges have been advised to consider his…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 67% of the sources lean Right
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
Ownership
To view ownership data please Upgrade to Vantage