Apple's 'Servant' Copyright Lawsuit Win Upheld on Appeal
The appeals court said the trial judge correctly applied copyright law and that jurors properly found no access to Francesca Gregorini’s film.
- On Thursday, the Ninth Circuit upheld a jury verdict clearing Apple Inc. and filmmaker M. Night Shyamalan of allegations that they stole an independent filmmaker's work for the Apple TV show "Servant," rejecting arguments of improper jury instructions.
- Italian-Born director Francesca Gregorini sued Apple and Shyamalan, alleging the show stole the plot from her 2013 film "The Truth About Emanuel," and she sought as much as $81 million in damages.
- Challenging the verdict, Gregorini argued the jury should have received detailed instructions on "widespread dissemination" and contested the trial judge's decision to accept the verdict without clarifying the term.
- Rejecting the appeal, the appeals court found the jury instructions accurately reflected applicable law and the trial judge did not abuse her discretion by accepting the unanimous verdict.
- A unanimous jury verdict in favor of Apple and Shyamalan had cleared the defendants early last year, as jurors found the show's creators had no access to Gregorini's film before development.
11 Articles
11 Articles
Appeals court upholds Apple TV's 'Servant' plagiarism lawsuit win
There's no twist ending for M. Nigh Shyamalan's day in court, as the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has maintained the ruling that Apple TV's "Servant" series did not copy a film titled "The Truth About Emanuel."'Servant' is a dramatic thriller series on Apple TVA lawsuit brought on by filmmaker Francesca Gregorini in January 2020 accused the creators of Servant of plagiarizing her film. The case was initially dismissed, but was then brought back …
Apple wins again in copyright infringement battle over Apple TV thriller series
The US Court of Appeals today upheld a verdict from early last year that cleared Apple of allegations that one of its hit thriller series was copied from a 2013 independent film.
9th Circ. Affirms Verdict Clearing Shyamalan Of Infringement
The Ninth Circuit on Thursday upheld a jury's decision clearing Apple Inc. and filmmaker M. Night Shyamalan of allegations that they stole an independent filmmaker's work for the Apple TV show "Servant," rejecting arguments of improper jury instructions.
Apple, Shyamalan convince US appeals court to uphold TV show copyright win
Court upholds verdict that Apple TV’s ‘Servant’ series didn’t rip off an independent film
The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit today upheld a verdict from early last year that cleared Apple of allegations that one of its Apple TV series, “Servant,” was a rip-off of an independent film.
An appeal court in the United States won Apple's case in Francesca Gregorini's plagiarism lawsuit against the Servant series,
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 100% of the sources are Center
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium











