Alex Murdaugh’s murder convictions are gone. Here’s what that means for a retrial
The justices said a county clerk’s comments tainted the jury and limited financial-crimes evidence in any retrial.
- On Wednesday, the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Alex Murdaugh's 2023 murder convictions, ruling that improper comments by former Colleton County Clerk of Court Rebecca Hill violated his right to a fair trial.
- The court's unanimous opinion cited the Remmer Presumption of Prejudice, stating Hill "placed her fingers on the scales of justice" by urging jurors to "watch him closely" during trial proceedings.
- Justices also provided guidance for any retrial, stating the state spent 12.5 hours on financial evidence with an "obviously high potential for unfair prejudice," advising prosecutors to limit such testimony.
- South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson stated his office will "aggressively continue the pursuit of justice" with a retrial goal before year's end, though defense attorney Richard Harpootlian argued logistical issues make a trial before January unlikely.
- Defense attorneys claim Murdaugh holds an advantage in retrial due to recorded testimony and knowledge of the prosecution's strategy, though experts suggest jury selection will be "tricky" given extensive media coverage and documentaries about the case.
55 Articles
55 Articles
By Ray Sanchez, CNN The dramatic fall from grace of former South Carolina lawyer Alex Murdaugh was sealed after a sensational six-week trial in 2023 in which he was convicted of murdering his wife and son. But the long saga involving the scion of a prominent and powerful local family of lawyers and prosecutors took an unexpected turn this week when the South Carolina Supreme Court on Wednesday overturned murder convictions. Stating that the tria…
Colbert’s Hissy Fit Farewell Tour, Xi’s Ominous Comment, & Murdaugh’s New Trial, w/ Glenn Greenwald
Megyn Kelly is joined by Glenn Greenwald, host of "System Update" on Substack, to discuss Stephen Colbert’s embarrassing hissy fit farewell tour destroying CBS furniture with David Letterman, how late night ratings over the past 20 years show the format completely collapsed, why he should just go out like a man, the tens of millions...
SHR 25.20: Update on redistricting, Murdaugh and Truman - Statehouse
The May 15, 2026, issue of Statehouse Report takes a look at what congressional redistricting could mean for South Carolina. In our news roundup, you can find information on the state Supreme Court overturning the murder convictions of disgraced high-profile lawyer Alex Murdaugh. Columnist Andy Brack has some choice words for state lawmakers about redistricting. The post SHR 25.20: Update on redistricting, Murdaugh and Truman appeared first on C…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 62% of the sources are Center
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
