Published • loading... • Updated
US troops could disobey questionable orders, Catholic archbishop says
Archbishop Broglio said disobeying orders against conscience is morally acceptable but risky for service members amid debated troop deployments and extreme policy options.
- On Sunday, Archbishop Timothy Broglio said disobeying an order that conflicts with a U.S. service member's conscience can be morally acceptable, though he acknowledged it would be difficult.
- Earlier this month, amid talk of seizing Greenland, Archbishop Timothy Broglio echoed church leaders in condemning such efforts and questioned attacking a friendly nation as President Donald Trump discussed being constrained only by his own morality.
- Legal experts warned under U.S. military law, troops must disobey manifestly unlawful orders though cases are complex; Brenner Fissell said the system is legal, not theological, and selective conscientious objection is not accepted.
Insights by Ground AI
14 Articles
14 Articles
+4 Reposted by 4 other sources
Archbishop says it’s ‘morally acceptable’ for troops to defy orders
The Catholic archbishop responsible for U.S. troops said it is “morally acceptable” for them to disobey an order if it is against their own conscience.
·Vienna, United States
Read Full ArticleArchbishop Challenges Moral Dilemmas in Military Orders
Archbishop Timothy Broglio, overseeing the U.S. military, called it morally acceptable for troops to disobey orders against their conscience. He expressed concerns about President Trump's military intentions, including occupying Greenland. Broglio's comments add to the growing disapproval among church leaders of Trump's foreign and immigration policies.
·India
Read Full ArticleCoverage Details
Total News Sources14
Leaning Left4Leaning Right1Center7Last UpdatedBias Distribution59% Center
Bias Distribution
- 59% of the sources are Center
59% Center
L 33%
C 59%
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium












