The federal Bureau of Prisons has lots of problems. Reopening Alcatraz is now one of them
- In early May 2025, President Donald Trump instructed the struggling Bureau of Prisons to renovate and reopen the historic Alcatraz Island prison.
- The Bureau of Prisons faces critical staffing shortages, chronic violence, and deteriorating infrastructure, all amid a systemic crisis predating the directive.
- Alcatraz, closed since 1963 due to high repair costs, was once the crown jewel holding notorious criminals like Al Capone and is now a popular tourist site.
- The Bureau manages over 155,000 inmates with a $8 billion budget, yet more than 4,000 beds are unusable, and 11 inmates died from mid-March to April 2025.
- Newly appointed director William Marshall emphasized the Bureau's commitment to addressing persistent systemic problems and reviving Alcatraz as a powerful emblem representing the principles of legal authority and fairness.
56 Articles
56 Articles
Trump's order to reopen Alcatraz is the perfect metaphor for his second term.
Analysis by Stephen Collinson, CNN Reabrir Alcatraz is such a typically trumpian idea that it's a miracle that the president hasn't tried it before. Locking criminals in tiny cells on an island surrounded by turbulent and murderous currents would feed President Donald Trump's hunger for sexist spectacle. Years after his closing in 1963, the prison became an icon of pop culture, with a tradition inspired by infamous stories of Mafia inmates like …
Alcatraz historian who lived on the island weighs in on reopening plan
Historian Jolene Babyak shares her experience of living at Alcatraz as a child with other families and outlines some of the issues at the prison island like no water, no sewage treatment, and disrepair of the aging buildings that would make President Trump’s plan of reopening difficult.
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 46% of the sources are Center
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
Ownership
To view ownership data please Upgrade to Vantage