Supreme Court to Hear Evangelist’s Challenge to Protest Ordinance
The case challenges whether a convicted protester can sue to prevent future enforcement of a local ordinance controlling protests near a concert venue, with broad implications for similar laws.
- On Wednesday, December 3, 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear Gabriel Olivier, Christian evangelist, challenge to City of Brandon, Mississippi's protest ordinance in Olivier v. City of Brandon.
- The City of Brandon enacted a 2019 ordinance forcing protesters into a designated protest area about 265 feet away, enforced three hours before and one hour after a ticketed event, with loudspeakers audible more than 100 feet prohibited.
- Olivier rejected the designated protest zone and deliberately moved out of it at a 2021 country music concert near the Brandon Amphitheater, leading to his arrest, a $304 fine, and a suspended ten-day jail sentence.
- Lower federal courts dismissed the case under Heck v. Humphrey, ruling Olivier's Section 1983 suit barred, while over 15 amicus briefs including the U.S. Solicitor General support him.
- The case raises a split that could resolve whether a convicted person may challenge a local protest rule in federal court, with Justice Clarence Thomas urging reexamination and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson cautioning against it.
19 Articles
19 Articles
High court considers pastor’s lawsuit over previously violated law
The Supreme Court considered on Wednesday whether to allow a Mississippi pastor to challenge the constitutionality of a law for future enforcement despite facing punishment for a previous violation of the law. Gabriel Olivier filed a lawsuit against a local law in Brandon, Mississippi, which bans protesting near a public amphitheater outside of designated zones, for which he has previously been punished for violating, in a bid to protect against…
Street preacher asks Supreme Court to overturn law limiting public protest
WASHINGTON — “Drunkards!” “Jezebel!” “Nasty!” The street preacher condemned people as he proselytized on the sidewalks outside public events. But after the town of Brandon, Mississippi, adopted an ordinance dictating where people are allowed to protest, Gabriel Olivier was arrested, fined and placed on one year of non-supervised probation. This was just the beginning of Olivier’s legal fight. He later filed a First Amendment lawsuit in federal c…
Supreme Court Justices Hear Street Preacher Who Challenged Law After Pleading No Contest to Breaking It
Justices didn’t seem to break along predictable lines Wednesday, when they presented critical questions to both sides in a case regarding a Christian pastor’s free speech challenge to a Mississippi city ordinance. In Olivier v. City of Brandon, the U.S. Supreme Court is weighing whether someone convicted under a law has standing to challenge the constitutionality of the law to prevent its future enforcement without nullifying a prior conviction…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 54% of the sources lean Right
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium













