US EditionReturn to Silent Hill Movie Review
Return to Silent Hill condenses Silent Hill 2 into 100 minutes with praised visuals and music but criticized for truncated characters and low-budget effects.
- On January 23, 2026, Return to Silent Hill opens in theaters, directed by Christophe Gans with a screenplay by Gans, Sandra Vo-Anh and Will Schneider, starring Jeremy Irvine as James Sunderland.
- Condensing the source material, the production chose a standalone tale rather than extending earlier Silent Hill films' mythology and compressed Silent Hill 2's lengthy narrative into a tight runtime.
- Anchored by its sound design, the film features series composer Akira Yamaoka's music and impressive creature designs, though reviewers say the 2024 Silent Hill 2 remake looks more visually refined and the film shows obvious green-screen backdrops.
- Reviewers find the movie surprisingly aimless with many supporting characters underdeveloped and Evie Templeton's Laura too brief to make an impact, while several performances feel uneven.
- For franchise fans, the film is seen as a disjointed retelling rather than a faithful adaptation, but it retains enough appeal to interest fans of Silent Hill amid rare strong video-game films.
12 Articles
12 Articles
Will Return to Silent Hill Be the Biggest Flop of 2026? — Video-Game-Turned-Horror-Series Roasted
Now, when a film adaptation of a super-popular video game arrives with years of built-in anticipation, there is always a big cloud of criticism over its head. Return to Silent Hill, the latest cinematic interpretation of the cult horror series, promised to give that eerie psychological dread and atmospheric terror that made the original games such fan favourites. Instead, early reviews say that the film may be in danger of becoming one of the bi…
Return to Silent Hill Movie Review
This is a spoiler-free review of Return to Silent Hill, which opens in theaters on January 23, 2026.Return to Silent Hill doesn’t necessarily have the highest bar to clear as it ambles its way to theaters in this winter lull period. Hollywood may have finally figured out how to do a proper video game adaptation on the streaming side of things, but decent video game movies are still pretty few and far between. And while director Cristophe Gans’ 2…
The new Silent Hill film, which adapts the second game, even underscores the 2012 review of Revelation.
The "Return to Silent Hill" Reviews Are In
While the reviews for “Mercy” are bad and the box-office looks weak, it’s in a better position than Christophe Gans’ “Return to Silent Hill,” which opens Friday. With 15 reviews counted, the film sits at a disastrous 7% on Rotten Tomatoes and a 30/100 on Metacritic. That’s behind Gans’ original 2006 film at 33% on RT and 31/100 on MC, and more in line with 2012’s “Silent Hill: Revelation” at 8% on RT and 16/100 on MC. This time, the film serves …
‘Return to Silent Hill’ Splats With Debut Score on Rotten Tomatoes
The latest installment of the Silent Hill movie series inspired by the video games is imminently arriving in theaters. Return to Silent Hill, based primarily on Silent Hill 2, is having its wide release on Jan. 23. Ahead of the launch, early reviews for the film are pouring in, but they’ve unfortunately slapped Return to Silent Hill with a very unwanted score on Rotten Tomatoes. Currently, Return to Silent Hill has an approval rating of just 7%.…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 67% of the sources lean Left
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
