Plotting Parents Murder Trial: Day 3 Recap

Plotting Parents Murder Trial: Day 3 Recap

Jeffrey Spence’s daughter, Carolyn Aguayo, took the stand and delivered scathing testimony about her father and his behavior. Spence is charged with murdering Kirby Carpenter. (9/29/25)

Hung Jury Mistrial Declared in Kirby Carpenter Murder Trial, Jury Deadlocked

A hung jury was declared in the Kirby Carpenter Murder Trial which concluded on Monday. Jurors were not able to come to a conclusion. Jeff Spence faced Capital Murder charges and after a 4 day trial, the jurors initially came back with a 6-6 deadlock before Judge Kelly Luther asked…