Published 11 minutes ago • loading... • Updated 2 hours ago
Court ruling throws wrench into Trump’s bid for offshore mining
The court said federal regulators failed to consider harm to endangered species and voided approval for a 31 million-acre lease sale.
On Monday, District Court Judge Jill Otake voided the Trump administration's approval of a lease sale for 31 million acres of Pacific Ocean seabed, ruling the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act by failing to assess environmental harms.
Seabed mining is a priority for President Trump, who signed an executive order last April instructing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to expedite mining approvals, despite global opposition from more than 45 countries citing significant risks to marine biodiversity.
Representing two plaintiffs, Earthjustice argued the government's determination was 'arbitrary and unlawful.' Judge Otake ruled that NMFS wrongfully adopted the Marine Minerals Administration's 'overly-narrow definition of the agency action,' failing to account for post-leasing environmental damage.
Attorney Chris Eaton called the ruling a 'huge victory' that renders the planned sale unlawful if it proceeds. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and the National Marine Fisheries Service declined to comment on the decision.
The implications of Monday's ruling could extend to proposed lease sales in waters off Alaska, Virginia, and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. Eaton expects the court to rule similarly on other pending legal challenges.