Police testimony contradicts defendant’s claims in decade-old Erie cold case

Police testimony contradicts defendant’s claims in decade-old Erie cold case

The man accused of killing an Erie woman more than 10 years ago appeared in Erie County Court Thursday morning for a preliminary hearing and continues this afternoon. Anthony D'Onofrio, 35, is accused of fatally shooting his finance 20-year-old Lexie Castile in September 2012. Suspect in decade-old cold case to be extradited to Erie However, D'Onofrio pleaded not guilty to homicide charges. Instead, the defense is claiming this is a suic…