US EditionCarrie Underwood Reacts to Simon Cowell Calling Her ‘Robotic’ on ‘American Idol’
- Carrie Underwood, who won American Idol Season 4 in 2005, responded to Simon Cowell calling her 'robotic' during her performance on the show.
- The comment followed Underwood's rendition of 'Bless the Broken Road,' which Cowell described as 'very good' and 'beautiful' but also 'a little robotic,' a view she later agreed with.
- Underwood addressed the feedback in a YouTube video released May 8 as part of American Idol's #IdolToIcon series while also sharing her social media motto 'Post and Ghost' on the current season of the show.
- Fellow judges praised her performance, with Randy Jackson calling it 'another great, perfect performance' and Paula Abdul impressed despite initial concerns over her song choice.
- Underwood's acknowledgment of Cowell's critique highlights her humility and deep connection to the show, where she now serves as a judge during Season 23 airing since March 9, 2025.
64 Articles
64 Articles
American Idol judge Carrie hits back at ex-judge Simon Cowell's savage critique
CARRIE Underwood has clapped back at Simon Cowell’s criticism- after he said she seemed “a little robotic” on stage. Current American Idol judge Carrie, 42, was looking back at footage of her performance 20 years ago, which saw her winning the show and launching her hugely successful career. Instagram / American IdolCarrie Underwood reckons Simon Cowell’s comments could have been worse[/caption] GettyCarrie is the first winner to return to the s…
Carrie Underwood Pregnant: Does She Want More Kids?
Reading Time: 4 minutes Is Carrie Underwood pregnant? The former American Idol champion has become one of the music world’s most beloved stars, and fans are always clamoring for new information about her personal life. And while she values her family’s privacy, Carrie posts to social media frequently, and she’s usually happy to share updates about her time away from the recording studio. But while fans might continue to bombard her with question…
American Idol judge Carrie Underwood hits back at ex-judge Simon Cowell's savage critique
CARRIE Underwood has clapped back at Simon Cowell’s criticism- after he said she seemed “a little robotic” on stage. Current American Idol judge Carrie, 42, was looking back at footage of her performance 20 years ago, which saw her winning the show and launching her hugely successful career. 6 Carrie Underwood reckons Simon Cowell’s comments could have been worseCredit: Instagram / American Idol 6 Carrie is the first winner to return to the sh…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 45% of the sources are Center
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
Ownership
To view ownership data please Upgrade to Vantage
