Skip to main content
See every side of every news story

Fifth Circuit Rules House Proxy Voting Made $1.7 Trillion Law Unconstitutional

United States

Elizabeth Frantz/Reuters

Elizabeth Frantz/Reuters

What Happened

An en banc 5th U.S. Circuit ruled 9–8 that proxy votes do not count for a quorum, finding the House unconstitutionally used proxy voting to pass the $1.7 trillion Appropriations Act of 2023. The court upheld an injunction blocking enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas.

Key Implications

Inimai Chettiar of A Better Balance said the ruling may reach beyond pregnant workers in states covered by the Fifth Circuit, and legal experts had warned it could affect other bills passed with proxy votes. Chettiar said district courts in those states would point to the opinion if employers denied accommodations and workers sued.

What Happened

An en banc 5th U.S. Circuit ruled 9–8 that proxy votes do not count for a quorum, finding the House unconstitutionally used proxy voting to pass the $1.7 trillion Appropriations Act of 2023. The court upheld an injunction blocking enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas.

Key Implications

Inimai Chettiar of A Better Balance said the ruling may reach beyond pregnant workers in states covered by the Fifth Circuit, and legal experts had warned it could affect other bills passed with proxy votes. Chettiar said district courts in those states would point to the opinion if employers denied accommodations and workers sued.

Where Sources Disagree

  • arrows_outputQuorum Clause Interpretation: The Fifth Circuit majority ruled that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause mandates physical presence to establish a quorum. Conversely, the dissenting opinion argued the Constitution contains no such requirement, maintaining that Congress possesses the authority to set its own procedural rules, including the use of proxy voting.
  • arrows_outputRuling Scope and Implications: Some reports emphasize the ruling’s narrow scope, noting the injunction only blocks enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas. However, other sources warn the decision creates broad, destabilizing implications by casting doubt on the validity of other laws passed using similar proxy voting procedures.

Timeline

November 20, 2026

Fifth Circuit Rules Proxy Unconstitutional: In a Nov. 20, 2026 en banc 9-8 decision the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that proxy votes do not count toward the Constitution's Quorum Clause, ruled the 2022 passage of the Consolidated Appropriations Act unconstitutional for quorum purposes, and restored a lower-court injunction blocking enforcement of the PWFA against Texas while limiting broader relief.

January 01, 2023

Texas Files Challenge, Injunction: Texas sued in 2023 arguing the House's proxy-presence rule violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause and sought injunctive relief; a federal district court enjoined the government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against Texas.

December 23, 2022

Spending Bill Passed By Proxy: At the end of 2022 the House used the proxy rule to pass the $1.7 trillion Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023; the House recorded 225-201 (one present) and legislative records show 226 of 427 members participated by proxy, leaving fewer than a majority physically in the chamber.

Summary by Ground AI

Sources

See All 40

A varied selection of sources chosen by Ground to reflect the diversity of this story’s coverage.

View All Sources

Similar News Topics

News
Feed Dots Icon
For You
Search Icon
Search
Blindspot LogoBlindspotLocal