UW Violated Professor’s Free Speech Rights, Court Rules
The Ninth Circuit ruled UW violated Professor Reges's rights after punishing him for parodying a land acknowledgment, emphasizing that student offense alone cannot justify retaliation.
- On Dec. 19, 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the district court, holding University of Washington violated Stuart Reges's First Amendment rights.
- Professor Stuart Reges mocked the university's recommended statement by placing a satirical land-acknowledgment on his Jan. 3, 2022 CSE 143 syllabus for a course of roughly 500 students, then sued with FIRE's support.
- The University of Washington noted numerous written complaints, including `I am intimidated and already do not feel welcome in this class, nor do I feel like I will be supported and led to be successful in this required course for my major,' and about one-third of students transferred out after UW created a competing section.
- UW is weighing a rehearing or Supreme Court appeal, while Reges remains on faculty seeking unspecified damages and to bar UW from creating shadow sections; FIRE hailed the ruling.
- Applying Pickering, the majority emphasized academic freedom in public universities, while Judge Sidney Thomas dissented, arguing disruption to Native students' learning outweighed Reges's speech interests.
11 Articles
11 Articles
Federal appeals court sides with Washington professor punished for mocking university land acknowledgment
University of Washington professor Stuart Reges wins free speech victory as federal appeals court rules officials violated his First Amendment rights over satirical land acknowledgment.
First Amendment Challenge to UW "Unacceptable or Inappropriate" Conduct Policy Revived
Another item from today's Ninth Circuit decision in Reges v. Cauce, written by Judge Daniel Bress and joined by Judge Milan Smith (for more on the primary portion of that opinion, see the UW Professor's Parody of Land Acknowledgment in Class Syllabus Protected by First Amendment post): Executive Order 31, UW's "Nondiscrimination and Affirmative Action" policy … begins …: The University of Washington, as an institution established and maintained …
9th Circuit Protects Professor’s First Amendment Right To Make Fun Of Land Acknowledgments
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled Friday that the University of Washington is not allowed to punish a professor for making fun of the “land acknowledgments” they tried to force on their staff. The win at the circuit level comes after the district court sided with the school. “A public university […]
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 60% of the sources lean Right
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium









