Published 1 day ago • loading... • Updated 6 hours ago
University of Michigan Pauses No-Grade Pilot Program for some Freshman Students
LSA has paused the program as faculty raise concerns about consultation and transcript access for students.
The University of Michigan has paused its LSA first-semester grade-covering pilot, originally scheduled for fall 2027. The program would have replaced traditional letter grades for incoming freshmen with "pass" or "no credit" designations.
Dean Rosario Ceballo proposed the pilot in her 2025 address to help the roughly 3,500 incoming freshmen "acclimate to the demands of a U-M education" and reduce stress and anxiety. The program aimed to encourage students to take classes outside their comfort zones without initial grades affecting their GPAs.
Critics, including former Michigan tight end Jake Butt, likened the grade-covering policy to "participation trophies" and argued it would blunt students' ability to grow. The backlash spread across social media and conservative outlets like Fox News last month.
U-M President Domenico Grasso requested the pause on Tuesday, stating that "distorted" media narratives unfairly portrayed students as "coddled or unprepared for the demands of a rigorous Michigan education." Grasso cited misconceptions that put the pilot's success at risk.
Regent Sarah Hubbard called the pause "a good decision," noting that stakeholders had questions requiring review. The Faculty Senate is drafting a document outlining faculty rights and responsibilities, with SACUA Chair Kentaro Toyama saying the work will span much of the year.