Mandy Moore Breaks Silence on Ashley Tisdale's Toxic Mom Group Essay
Moore said the essay’s implication that she was unkind was upsetting and said she has found meaningful support from other parents.
- On Monday, May 18, Mandy Moore addressed Ashley Tisdale French's viral essay about a "toxic" mom group during an appearance on SiriusXM's Andy Cohen Live, calling the public airing "decidedly way more upsetting" than other media commentary.
- French published "Breaking Up With My Toxic Mom Group" in The Cut earlier this year, where the former Disney Channel star reflected on feeling excluded from her friend group, sparking speculation she was referring to Moore and Hilary Duff.
- Emphasizing that "being a kind person" is her life's priority, Moore stated she is "really scared by confrontation" but finds the implication her group was petty "very upsetting."
- Rejecting the notion women are "inherently" petty, Moore criticized the "ridiculous debacle" for perpetuating a "silly trope," noting she has found only support from fellow mothers since becoming a parent.
- Duff previously responded in February, admitting she felt "really sad" and "taken aback" by the claims, while French's representative has not confirmed the specific identities of the group members.
24 Articles
24 Articles
Mandy Moore Shocked by Ashley Tisdale’s ‘Toxic’ Mom Essay That Implied She and Others Are Unkind: ‘Wow'
Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images Mandy Moore is finally speaking out about the essay that sparked weeks of speculation around a celebrity mom friend group. The actress said she was deeply unsettled by Ashley Tisdale’s comments, which many readers believed referenced Moore, Hilary Duff, Meghan Trainor, and their circle. The controversy began in January when Tisdale published an essay titled “Breaking Up with My Toxic Mom Group.” In the piece, s…
Mandy Moore joins the mommy group discourse, says Ashley Tisdale's scathing essay 'cuts to the core'
Mandy Moore shared her take on the drama swirling around her celebrity mommy group, months after fellow child actor Ashley Tisdale shaded the bunch in a scathing essay last winter.
Mandy Moore Has No Time For Ashley Tisdale's Toxic Mom Group Essay
Jason Kempin/Getty Images Entertainment; Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images EntertainmentMandy Moore’s relationship with Ashley Tisdale French isn’t all “Candy.” On the May 18 episode of SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live, the actor-singer responded to Tisdale’s viral essay for The Cut, where she wrote about leaving a “toxic mom group.” Internet sleuths connected the dots to Moore and Hilary Duff, who was part of a friend group with Tisdale, as seen in variou…
Ashley Tisdale & Hilary Duff’s Mom Group Drama Explained
Ashley Tisdale ignited a fire with her essay from The Cut entitled “Breaking Up With My Toxic Mom Group” released on New Year’s Day 2026. In the short tome, the High School Musical Star attempted to anonymously chronicle the drama between her and her then-unknown group of mothers she used to call friends. “I felt lucky when my friend brought together a group of new moms that she knew. My friend’s friends were in the same situation as I was. Mo…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 67% of the sources lean Left
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
