Published 27 days ago • loading... • Updated 27 days ago
Supreme Court hears church warden murder appeal
Justices are weighing whether Field legally caused Farquhar’s death after prosecutors said he secretly gave him drugs and spiked his whisky to hide the killing.
On Tuesday, five Supreme Court justices concluded a hearing examining whether the trial judge's directions on legal causation in Benjamin Field's murder conviction were correct.
Field was jailed for at least 36 years in 2019 for murdering 69-year-old Peter Farquhar, but the Court of Appeal quashed his conviction last year, prompting the Crown Prosecution Service to challenge that decision.
Defense lawyers argued the act of providing whisky or Dalmane was not a "legally effective cause of death," while the CPS argued the judge correctly recognized Field's plan made him legally responsible.
David Perry KC told the court Field had "set out cynically to seduce Mr Farquhar" and "covertly" administered drugs, saying there would be "no dispute" regarding guilt if Farquhar was misled about substances.
This case previously inspired the 2023 BBC drama The Sixth Commandment, and the justices are currently deliberating on whether Field could be held responsible if Farquhar independently chose to consume the substances.