Vanity Fair Report Says JD Vance Advised Clinton Campaign on Midwest
United States
Matt Rourke-Pool/Getty Images/Getty
What Happened
What Happened
Where Left Sources Focus
- 2016 Strategic Advice: Left and center outlets detail how JD Vance offered specific strategic advice to Hillary Clinton's 2016 campaign, including suggestions that she visit 'Blue Wall' states and apologize for the Iraq War, citing a new report from Vanity Fair.
- Political Metamorphosis Analysis: Coverage in these outlets examines Vance's dramatic political evolution from a vocal Trump critic who once labeled him 'America's Hitler' to his current role as a MAGA vice president, framing the shift as a rejection of elite hypocrisy.
Where Right Sources Focus
- Denial of Campaign Assistance: Right-leaning media emphasize the official denial from Vance's spokesperson, who explicitly rejected the characterization that Vance intended to help Hillary Clinton win the 2016 election, citing statements from Taylor Van Kirk.
- Working-Class Advocacy Frame: Right-leaning sources frame Vance's 2016 outreach as non-partisan advocacy for working-class communities in Ohio, rather than political campaigning, noting that he urged politicians from both parties to address the needs of his hometown.
What's Largely Absent from Each Side
- Right sources rarely mention: Right-leaning coverage largely omits specific details of the advice Vance reportedly offered, such as suggesting Clinton apologize for the Iraq War, which left and center outlets emphasize as evidence of his strategic involvement.
- Left sources rarely mention: Left and center sources rarely mention that Vance was a prominent Trump critic who also disliked Clinton in 2016, omitting context about his support for independent candidate Evan McMullin that right-leaning outlets feature prominently.
Rare Agreement
- 2016 Contact Event: Despite divergent coverage patterns, sources across the political spectrum confirm that Vance reached out to the Clinton campaign in 2016, spoke directly with adviser Jake Sullivan, and that his spokesperson has formally denied he intended to aid her election efforts.
Timeline
September 17, 2026
Vanity Fair report and responses: In September 2026 Chris Whipple’s Vanity Fair profile revealed Vance’s 2016 outreach and direct contact with Jake Sullivan; Vance’s spokesperson Taylor Van Kirk strongly disputed the characterization that he was trying to help Clinton win, while coverage noted Vance’s later political transformation to a Trump ally and vice president. Whipple told NPR his reporting indicates Vance was privately trying to help Clinton defeat Trump.
November 08, 2016
Urged Midwest campaigning and apology: According to Vanity Fair reporting, Vance advised the Clinton campaign to focus on Midwestern swing states—Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania—and to repair damage from her 'basket of deplorables' comment by addressing working-class concerns, including apologizing for support of the Iraq War. Sources say he argued she should campaign in those 'Blue Wall' states rather than attend celebrity events elsewhere.
September 27, 2016
Direct call with Jake Sullivan: Whipple’s reporting says Vance ultimately spoke directly with senior Clinton adviser Jake Sullivan roughly six weeks before Election Day and was insistent that Clinton 'fix' her messaging after the 'basket of deplorables' remark. Vanity Fair frames that direct contact as part of Vance’s back-channel efforts in 2016.
Summaries by Ground AI
Sources
See All 21Most Written About
The stories getting the most coverage from the last 24 hours
Timeline
September 17, 2026
Vanity Fair report and responses: In September 2026 Chris Whipple’s Vanity Fair profile revealed Vance’s 2016 outreach and direct contact with Jake Sullivan; Vance’s spokesperson Taylor Van Kirk strongly disputed the characterization that he was trying to help Clinton win, while coverage noted Vance’s later political transformation to a Trump ally and vice president. Whipple told NPR his reporting indicates Vance was privately trying to help Clinton defeat Trump.
November 08, 2016
Urged Midwest campaigning and apology: According to Vanity Fair reporting, Vance advised the Clinton campaign to focus on Midwestern swing states—Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania—and to repair damage from her 'basket of deplorables' comment by addressing working-class concerns, including apologizing for support of the Iraq War. Sources say he argued she should campaign in those 'Blue Wall' states rather than attend celebrity events elsewhere.
September 27, 2016
Direct call with Jake Sullivan: Whipple’s reporting says Vance ultimately spoke directly with senior Clinton adviser Jake Sullivan roughly six weeks before Election Day and was insistent that Clinton 'fix' her messaging after the 'basket of deplorables' remark. Vanity Fair frames that direct contact as part of Vance’s back-channel efforts in 2016.
