Skip to main content
See every side of every news story
Published • loading... • Updated

Transcontinental merger of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern divides rail leaders

Creative Investment Research says the deal could deliver $4.2 billion to $5.8 billion in annual economic, climate and public-health benefits.

Summary by FreightWaves
Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern promise lasting service gains, while some rivals question the competitive consequences of their proposed combination.

4 Articles

Rail Shift: What a coast-to-coast railroad could mean for Chicago industrial

Each day, roughly 1,000 trucks haul freight across Chicago between Union Pacific’s terminals and those operated by CSX and Norfolk Southern for a single reason: the cargo is changing railroads. Union Pacific says its proposed merger with Norfolk Southern would eliminate the need for those crosstown moves. The combined company would be what the railroads call the first single-line, coast-to-coast freight rail service in the U.S. with the railroads targeting a close in the third or fourth quarter of 2027, pending Surface Transportation Board approval. For an industrial market that grew up around the handoff between eastern and western carriers, the question is which properties gain and which lose. In a Sept. 16 release, Union Pacific said more than 500 customers have publicly backed the combination, which the companies estimate would generate about $3.5 billion in annual savings and shift 2.1 million truckloads a year from highways to rail. The railroads also argue that eliminating the Chicago interchange would cut 24 to 48 hours from existing transit times, according to FreightWaves. The opposition is organized too. The Stop the Rail Merger Coalition counts 13 members including rival railroads BNSF and CPKC, the American Chemistry Council, the American Farm Bureau Federation and the Teamsters Rail Conference. “Lately, the pendulum has shifted slightly against the merger,” said Joseph Schwieterman, Professor at DePaul University. “Rather than pockets of resistance, there now seems to be more coordinated resistance.” Schwieterman counts more run-through trains among the merger’s clear benefits for the region. “Right now, a lot of cargo, containers in particular, moves between yards by truck,” Schwieterman said. “That creates congestion and safety concerns in neighborhoods, particularly on the South Side, and as truck traffic grows, it’s become a massive problem. Fewer rubber-tire movements would help significantly, though it would likely mean a modest reduction in jobs in Chicago, because so much labor is devoted to dealing with all that inefficiency.” Northmarq’s analysis traces Chicago’s industrial market to the interchange itself. If the handoff moves inside one carrier, part of the drayage and transloading business built around it would lose its purpose, leaving Logistics Park Chicago, the I-80 Corridor and properties near Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern yards exposed. “The proposed merger may indeed reduce the number of interchanges between rail lines and increase the number of trains through the region,” said Jeff Lanaghan, Senior Vice President of Development and Investments at Becknell Industrial. “However, if delivery times are shortened, rail delivery will become more competitive with trucking, which could actually increase the volume of rail into the Metro Chicago area.” Lanaghan expects the I-80 and I-55 corridors to keep drawing requirements because of the Joliet and Elwood intermodal yards. Keith Stauber, Managing Director of Leasing at JLL, sees potential for the merger to add modest growth along I-80, home to Union Pacific’s Global IV terminal, the Midwest’s primary gateway for containers arriving through the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach. “It hasn’t reached our real estate conversations with tenants or investors yet, and it won’t until the merged company says which facilities will stay open and which will close,” Stauber said. Most of Norfolk Southern’s Chicago facilities sit inside the city, Stauber noted, while Union Pacific’s are concentrated in the near west suburbs and Joliet. He expects a merged railroad to shut or combine yards that are underused or boxed in. “The closer-in yards that remain are the ones to watch, because they will need more docks and more room for containers, both already scarce in infill submarkets,” Stauber said. “That should mean more teardowns and new Class A buildings for rail users, which is a real opportunity for developers with the creativity and patience for complicated projects.” He also sees an opening for owners of nearby industrial outdoor storage sites that offer trailer and container parking, and some tenants are already asking about shifting more freight to rail as fuel costs climb, he said. Lanaghan sees limits on how much of that interest turns into demand for rail-served buildings. “In spite of the abundance of rail lines into the market, there are relatively few pure rail requirements on an annual basis,” Lanaghan said. “The existing intermodal locations will continue to capture the 3PL demand associated with the rail traffic.” Shippers could also lose leverage. Companies that can route imports through either coast can often choose among six railroads, including the two Canadian carriers, Schwieterman said, and the merger would take away one of those choices. If regulators approve the deal, he expects extensive reciprocal switching requirements to protect customers’ options. He also cited Canadian Pacific’s merger with Kansas City Southern, which never moved as much freight off trucks as hoped, as a reason for skepticism about the projected benefits. For now, the review isn’t moving deals. Northmarq says the merger is not yet a material factor in decisions. Underwriting has grown more careful about assumptions involving rail-dependent demand for large logistics users, though the firm calls that prudent diligence rather than a response to the merger. Highway-dependent demand faces no such question, since Chicago remains the hub of the U.S. road system regardless of who runs the trains. “Chicago’s strength comes from its geographical location, and the rail interchange activity is a bonus,” Lanaghan said.

Think freely.Subscribe and get full access to Ground NewsSubscriptions start at $9.99/yearSubscribe

Bias Distribution

  • 34% of the sources lean Left, 33% of the sources are Center, 33% of the sources lean Right
34% Left

Factuality Info Icon

To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium

Ownership

Info Icon

To view ownership data please Upgrade to Vantage

REJournals broke the news on Tuesday, November 17, 2026.
Too Big Arrow Icon
Sources are mostly out of (0)

Similar News Topics

News
Feed Dots Icon
For You
Search Icon
Search
Blindspot LogoBlindspotLocal