Published 14 minutes ago • loading... • Updated 2 hours ago
Supreme Court of Canada Upholds Conviction for Aggravated Sexual Assault
The court said judges must instruct juries on consent and ruled there is no legal requirement that a complainant communicate non-consent.
On Friday, the Supreme Court of Canada released two judgments clarifying consent laws in sexual-assault cases, ruling there is no legal requirement for a complainant to communicate non-consent to sexual contact.
In one case, the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the conviction of Bevin Kerry Deagle after the Ontario Court of Appeal had previously overturned his initial acquittal for aggravated sexual assault.
Separately, the court rejected Jordan Bilinski's appeal by a 7-2 margin, upholding the Alberta Court of Appeal's order for a new trial following his 2023 acquittal.
Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau wrote the majority judgment, though the court split 5-4 on legal reasoning regarding jury instructions on consent in sexual-assault cases.
These rulings mark one of the final cases for Justice Sheilah Martin, who wrote concurring reasons before retiring, cementing her legacy in criminal law and Charter of Rights and Freedoms expertise.