Published 23 hours ago • loading... • Updated 23 hours ago
Advocates debate U.S. Supreme Court expansion
Advocates clashed over adding justices, while Roman Buhler backed a constitutional amendment to lock the court at nine members.
The Cato Institute hosted a debate on Monday about expanding the Supreme Court, with experts weighing whether increasing the bench from nine to 13 justices would foster bipartisanship or undermine judicial independence.
Congress failed to pass a cap on the number of justices by a vote of 212-206 in September, prompting calls for reform from Democratic leaders including Rep. Hakeem Jeffries.
Stephen Feldman argued the court's conservative decisions align with President Donald Trump's priorities, citing the reversal of 90-year-old precedent in Trump v. Slaughter. Roman Buhler countered that adding justices would invite further politicization.
Buhler defended overruling decisions like Plessy v. Ferguson, calling it a great moment in American history when the Supreme Court overturned segregation in Brown versus Board of Education.
To restore the court's independence, Buhler advocated for a constitutional amendment capping justices at nine, arguing expansion would only deepen politicization rather than restore apolitical decision-making.