US EditionThe Shadow Docket Is John Roberts’ Disappointing Legacy
Leaked internal memos show the court used a secret five-day exchange to block the Obama administration’s Clean Power Plan and create a new emergency-order practice.
- A New York Times investigation published last week revealed the secret origins of the Supreme Court's "shadow docket," exposing how Chief Justice John Roberts quietly rewrote judicial rules during five days of confidential memo exchanges in February 2016.
- This emergency process allows the Court to make quick decisions without full briefing and deliberation; University of Texas law professor Stephen Vladeck characterizes it as making "consequential decisions behind closed doors" without public explanation.
- The docket enabled the 2017 Trump Travel Ban, which partially reinstated travel restrictions before full case arguments, and the 2021 Texas Abortion Law, which took effect via an unsigned, one-paragraph order issued without public debate.
- Public trust in the judiciary has declined sharply; according to Gallup, 52% of Americans disapproved of the Supreme Court as of September 2025, while Pew Research Center found favorable views dropped to 48% from 70% five years earlier.
- This pattern continues in recent cases: in March 2026, the Court halted a state order on the New York Congressional Map, and ongoing deliberations involve Haitian nationals' temporary protected status, which critics argue advances conservative policy priorities.
26 Articles
26 Articles
The shadow docket is John Roberts’ disappointing legacy
Chief Justice John Roberts was the driving force behind the rise of the Supreme Court’s emergency docket as a powerful tool to empower the activist conservative majority — that’s the main takeaway of a cache of memos leaked to the…
The Supreme Court’s ‘Shadow Docket' Rulings Are Undermining the Rule of Law - Bucks County Beacon
The New York Times exposed the secret origins of the Supreme Court’s “shadow docket” and its impact on our democracy. Most Americans have never heard of the “shadow docket.” But if you have wondered how the Supreme Court could block clean air and water guidelines in the middle of the night, halt an election rule days before voters go to the polls, or allow a Texas abortion ban to take effect without a single day of oral argument — the answer lie…
NYTimes Unveils How SCOTUS Created 'Shadow Docket' Rulings
The Times takes a deep dive into leaked SCOTUS memos related to the origins and implementation of the infamous "shadow docket" rulings. TLDR; is how John Roberts argued they should stop Obama's attempt to regulate coal-fired power plants. In public, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. has cultivated a reputation for care and caution. The papers reveal a different side of him. At a critical moment for the country and the court, the papers show, he …
Hypocritically, The Origin Of The Supreme Court’s ‘Shadow Docket’ Was An Attempt To Curb Executive Power
I originally began this headline with the word "ironically." But it would only be ironic if it wasn't by design. Irony suggests something slightly out of the control of the principal figures resulted in something somewhat unexpected. That isn't the case here. This was by design. The New York Times has obtained the behind-the-scenes memos…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 48% of the sources lean Left
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
